Unreported Income (IRS): CPA Liability

The IRS has a new method for identifying returns with a high probability for unreported income (i.e., Unreported Income Discriminate Index Function (UI DIF)). Unreported income is both civil tax fraud and criminal tax evasion.

Taxpayers who have unreported income may be subject to up to 6 years in prison, 100% penalties and fines, and expose their accountants to civil and criminal liability.

1. Statutes of Limitations
a. Civil Tax Fraud: No statute of limitations on assessment (tax can be assessed at any time)
b. Criminal Tax Evasion: For crimes, the statute of limitations is either 3, 5 or 6 years, only on the prosecution of the crime (i.e., tax evasion, not the assessment of tax owed)

2. Burdens of Proof
a. Civil Tax Fraud: “Clear and Convincing Evidence”
b. Criminal Tax Evasion: “Beyond a Reasonable Doubt”

3. Penalties/Fines
a. Civil Tax Fraud
i. Fraudulent Failure to File Tax Return: (IRC §6651(f))
ii. Fraudulent Tax Return Filed: (IRC §6663(a))
Maximum Penalty: 75% of tax due
iii. Failure to Pay Tax:
Shown on Return (IRC §6651(a)(2)),
Not Shown on Return (IRC §6651(a)(3))
Maximum Penalty: 25% of tax due

b. Criminal Tax Evasion
i. IRC §7201: Evade Tax
Fine: $100,000 (individual) $500,000 (corporate)
Imprisonment: not more than 5 years (or both fine and imprisonment)

ii. IRC §7203: Failure to File or Pay Tax
Fine: $25,000 (individual) $100,000 (corporate)
Imprisonment: up to one year (or both fine and imprisonment)

As a tax preparer, if a client has unreported income:
1. What is your liability re: IRC §6694 preparer penalties?
2. If you advise the client to report the income, do you prepare the tax return, or advise the client to engage an attorney to hire a CPA to prepare the tax return (for attorney-client privilege)?
3. If you advise your client to file or amend a tax return, is it a voluntary disclosure with no criminal liability? Is there any criminal liability for you?